Once Again Nut Butter
Last verified: April 2026
Read our full verification: Is Once Again Nut Butter Made in USA?Est. 1976
Once Again Nut Butter has been manufacturing products in Nunda, NY since 1976. We carry 5 verified American-made Once Again Nut Butter products.
Heritage & History
Once Again Nut Butter was founded in 1976 in the Finger Lakes region of New York, where it remains today. The company began as part of the natural foods movement emerging in small towns and college communities across the Northeast — a reaction against the highly processed, heavily sweetened peanut butters that dominated grocery shelves.
The founders' commitment was simple: nut butters made from roasted nuts and nothing else. No added sugar, no hydrogenated oils, no palm oil, no salt unless the customer wanted it. The company adopted an employee-owned cooperative structure that remains in place today, giving workers direct stakes in the business's success.
Made in Nunda, New York
Once Again's facility in Nunda, New York produces all of the company's nut butters, tahini, and honey products using stone-grinding equipment that produces a naturally smooth texture without high-heat processing. The stone grinding method is slower than modern high-speed equipment, but it preserves more of the nuts' natural oils and flavor compounds.
The company sources organic and conventional peanuts from US farmers, organic sunflower seeds, and almonds from California growers. Products are certified USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, and kosher. The commitment to glass jars — rather than plastic — reflects the cooperative's long-standing interest in reducing packaging waste, a value that predates modern sustainability marketing by decades.
Quick Picks
Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter 16 oz
Once Again Nut Butter
Food & Beverages
Once Again Organic Sunflower Butter 16 oz
Once Again Nut Butter
Food & Beverages
Once Again Organic Creamy Almond Butter 16 oz
Once Again Nut Butter
Food & Beverages
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Once Again Nut Butter made in the USA?
Yes. Once Again Nut Butter manufactures 5 verified products in Nunda, NY. Once Again Nut Butter is a worker-owned cooperative in Nunda, New York that has been making organic and natural nut butters since 1976, using traditional stone-grinding methods.
Where is Once Again Nut Butter manufactured?
Once Again Nut Butter is headquartered in Nunda, NY. Manufacturing takes place in Nunda, NY.
What Once Again Nut Butter products can I buy?
We carry 5 verified Once Again Nut Butter products across Food & Beverages. Every listing links directly to Amazon with verified American manufacturing.
When was Once Again Nut Butter founded?
Once Again Nut Butter was founded in 1976. Once Again Nut Butter is a worker-owned cooperative in Nunda, New York that has been making organic and natural nut butters since 1976, using traditional stone-grinding methods.
Does Once Again Nut Butter ship from Amazon?
Yes, all Once Again Nut Butter products listed here are available on Amazon with free shipping for Prime members.